This new 'Lost' imitator is a little more promising than past 'Lost' imitators. However, 'Revolution's first hour makes it abundantly clear that network executives still don't truly understand why the island-set mystery ever worked in the first place.
I write this knowing perfectly well that J.J. Abrams has a producer credit for Revolution--a producer credit that really serves more as an endorsement for the show. Abrams neither wrote nor directed the pilot of Revolution. Compare that with Lost, where he both co-wrote and directed the pilot and then played a key role in setting up the first hints at a larger mythology. Now, Revolution was written by Eric Kripke (Supernatural) and directed by Jon Favreau (Iron Man). Two men who are definitely capable of creating an intriguing television show about a world that exists without electricity. It just seems doubtful that the suits at NBC will allow Kripke and his writers make such a version of the show.